REVIEW OF WORSHIP TIMES AND STYLES
BACKGROUND
In November, 2008, the Church Council decided that 2009 was to be a year
of experiment in worship times and styles. The Review Period would be
Jan-March 2010. After the Review the Council would decide a future pattern.
THE REASONS for this experiment were considered to be:
- Our average congregation size was diminishing.
- Our local area was experiencing large changes brought about by the
extension of the University site.
- All national church growth advice concurs that a monthly pattern of
different services (which we had) is a deterrent to new people coming
to church. Monthly patterns deter regular churchgoers from coming to
church weekly as they wish to worship in a preferred way.
- Every Sunday morning the experimental pattern would give everyone
a choice between quieter traditional worship or more contemporary worship
friendly to children.
THE EXPERIMENT
1. The times of Sunday morning services were moved one hour later and
each had a regular weekly distinctive style.
2. The Thursday morning communion service was moved from 8.45 am to 9.15
am. This was shortly after the school start and within the permitted time
for bus pass users to arrive.
THE PLUSES AND MINUSES OF THE EXPERIMENT
PLUSES |
MINUSES |
Numbers have stopped falling !!!!!
Coffee time good for Woodlands guests
Coffee time gives clergy time to mix
Focussed Services easier for clergy to lead
11 am is attracting more students
Music is blossoming at 11 am
Option of preferred style of worship every week
Everyone knows what to expect each week
Flexible at 11 am without HC every week
More opportunity for lay involvement
Services can be child-friendly every week
2009 Parade Service numbers were increased
|
Fears of becoming two congregations
Few 11 am people come early for coffee
Difficulties in staffing for coffee
11 am too late for some families
9 am service too early for some elderly
9 am could do with a more musical variety
Two services could separate generations
A double appointment for visiting preachers
Increased time commitment for Rory |
SOME UNAVOIDABLE PRACTICALITIES
1) For 2010, Nancy will need extra time to work out hand-over strategies
and processes for many of her duties and responsibilities. Rory's hours
will need to incorporate involvement in more of the church's day-to-day
management and he will be away on Sabbatical leave at Easter and in August/September
for a total of three months.
2) From 16th January 2011, our clergy team will consist of Rory (+/-10
hrs a week), Rowan Williams (2 Sundays a month) and, hopefully, clergy
cover for worship services by arrangement with other local parishes. Our
only Reader, John, will not be here to fill any gaps in the services.
SUGGESTED WAYS FORWARD
Suggestion One
We continue with a 9.00 am traditional Communion with hymns and organ,
and an 11.00 am Morning Service with monthly Communion, mostly contemporary
music and less formal liturgy. The Thursday Communion remains as it is
now.
This pattern has halted the decline in numbers. It offers a clear choice
of service styles. 2010 will be a year of transition. We do not know what
the future holds in terms of Anglican clergy support and oversight. We
might be wise not to introduce further change, but wait together to see
what is possible after Jan 2011.
Suggestion Two
One united Sunday morning service at 10.30 am. This service would be a
contemporary service with some hymns and occasional use of the organ.
It would have a monthly Communion and coffee after the service. In addition,
a traditional Communion Service with hymns will take place on a weekday
morning at 9.30 am, with coffee time.
a) Some of the congregation miss feeling that the majority of the church
is together in one service, and miss the opportunity to talk and mingle
afterwards. Coffee time has not been what we had hoped it might be this
year.
b) A 9 am start for our first service is a real difficulty for some. The
band needs an hour to set up, prepare and practise.
c) 11 am is a good time for students, but not the best time for some of
those with children and young families. A service slightly earlier might
be more helpful to families.
d) A traditional, liturgical, quieter Communion service is appreciated.
Hymns are valued as part of this.
Suggestion Three
We have the original times of 8.00 am and 10.00 am for Sunday morning
Worship
This was the established pattern for many years which has nurtured many
long standing members of the congregation. 2009 was agreed to be an experiment
rather than the established pattern.
a) 10.00 am is an easier time than 9.00 am for some older members
b) The majority of the church members can worship together at 10.00 am
on a Sunday
Questions we have ?
a) What will be lost if we simply abandon everything that has developed
through 2009?
b) Can a single service on a Sunday morning cater for different needs
for worship without becoming unduly long?
c) How can a desire for quiet worship be reconciled with the presence
of children?
d) How can the needs of children and families be met?
e) Is it right to insist on a “one size fits all” service
on a Sunday morning.
f) How can those who struggle to arrive by 9 am be helped if the traditional
Sunday service continues?
g). What has been good about the current 9.00 am and 11.00 am Sunday service
pattern and what has caused problems for you?
h). What are your thoughts about a single contemporary Sunday morning
service (with communion once a month) at 10.30 am and a mid-week communion
service with hymns at 9.30 am?
i). What about having an earlier traditional said 8.00 am Communion and
a 10.00 am more contemporary service ?
j). In view of Nancy's retirement, what is the best of the three options
for the future of Heslington church?
Some of these questions will be considered at 9.00 am and 11 am services
on 7th February. Also there is a box for written replies under the display
in the entrance to church. If you wish to email comments please do so
to heslington.church@hotmail.co.uk by 17th February 2010
Church Council Meeting, January 2010
- The review of worship times and styles was the main
item on the agenda. It was with some dismay that the Council heard that
some had already made up their minds and were considering the outcome
a done deal. This is by no means the case. There will be ample opportunity
for all views to be heard and considered. The final decision will not
be made until the 17th March Church Council so everyone is urged to
consider all the options and join in the review in the best spirit.
- The finances of the church have improved remarkably
during the last three months of 2009. Many thanks are due to Karl Jarvis
our churchwarden, who took over as temporary treasurer at very short
notice. Many thanks also to all the congregation who increased regular
giving or made very welcome and generous one-off donations. Our deficit
from 2008 is paid off. A considerable amount has been been paid off
the Diocesan Quota for 2009. There is a stiff challenge still to meet
for 2010, but the new treasurer, Stephen Connor, has taken over now
and there are fund-raising events planned.
- The organ will soon be repaired and in use again.
There will be a Praise and Pancakes evening on Shrove Tuesday to celebrate
this and hopefully raise some of the remaining money needed to pay the
bill. The top ten favourite hymns, chosen by the congregation, will
be sung and there will be a plate for donations to the Organ Fund. The
total amount raised so far for the organ is £10,831 and we need
to raise about £1,100 more, so let us try to persevere for this
last amount, Come and sing - came and enjoy the pancakes - come and
help the Organ Fund.
Church Council meeting, November 2009
-
New members
Susan Pearce, Marie Glenton and Greg Melia (returning member) were
welcomed onto the Church Membership List.
The Council expressed thanks to Dorothy Scott and David Heppell who
were having to leave the Church Council for family reasons. Stephen
Connor and Rick Taylor were welcomed onto the Church Council as co-opted
members.
-
Review of worship times and styles
This is set to start at the beginning of January. The Worship Forum
(which is open to everyone) will meet in December to formulate the
process so it can have a prompt start. All interested parties will
be encouraged to contribute their responses and the Church Council
will decide the future way forward at its meeting in March.
-
Finance
Since the resignation of Stuart Turner, Karl Jarvis our Church Warden
has most ably stepped into the breach for the interim time until the
end of 2009. On 1st January 2010 Stephen Connor was unanimously elected
to serve as Heslington Church Tresurer. There has been some improvement
to our financial situation (though we are not out of the woods yet!)
and many thanks are due to everyone who has increased their giving
to the church.
The Church Council voted to use some of the generous legacy money
(from Shaun Meynell and Alan Mott) to upgrade the sound system.
Church Council Meeting, September 2009
- The university is open to talks regarding a small extension of our
churchyard into Dean's Acre.
-
Firms are coming to look at the sound system with
the hope that we can improve the quality of the sound and also provide
some visual facility.
- The new shade of pew runners was approved.
-
The Worship Forum has done some work on the ways
we shall assess the experimental year in times and styles. This review
will begin in January as planned and all comments will be sought.
-
Stuart Turner, our treasurer, has resigned. There
will be interim arrangements until such time that a new treasurer
can be appointed. In the meantime all financial information should
go to the Church Warden, Karl Jarvis.
-
We are starting a new venture - a youth club -
as a result of a request from the junior leaders at the summer club.
The Youth Club will meet on Thursdays 6.30pm - 8.00pm and the leaders
will be Rachel Stephenson, Greg Melia and John Eckersley.
-
There will be various fun fund-raising activities
happening. Please read the newsletter or look at the website for details.
Church Council meeting 22nd July 2009
-
After nine months of debate, the Church Council
has decided to request that the parish moves from Derwent Deanery
into York Deanery.
-
The financial situation of our church is getting
ever more serious. A fund-raising committee has been formed and church
members are to be asked to support events. Stewardship Sunday will
be on 27th September this year.
-
The floor of the narthex and the main church is
to be cleaned and polished. This will necessitate a complete four-day
closure of the church in early September (not affecting Sunday worship).
-
The Church Council watched the diocesan DVD "Listening
to the experiences of Gay and Lesbian Christians". There will
be an evening for the congregation and community to watch this DVD
and participate in discussion on Monday 28th September at 7.30pm in
church.
May Church Council Meeting
- David, Linda and Jenni Clements were welcomed onto the membership
list.
-
Pew runners received the thumbs up from the Diocesan
Authorities but we cannot have them in red (to match the organ red!)
A new colour is being discussed.
-
The Acting Rural Dean of York, Rev. Terence McDonough,
came to help us in our deanery deliberations. Changing deanery to
York would enable the chaplaincy to link better with York (St. John)
University; tie in the Archbishop Holgate School work better and enable
the church to have more links with a dynamic York scene. The Council
will be voting on the proposal to change deaneries at its July meeting.
If you have views on this matter please speak to a Church Council
member.
-
Our financial situation is still in the red. There
has been some increased giving but every month our situation is worsening
as our required outgoings are more than our income. The Finance Committee
will announce further fund-raising measures.
-
Heslington is once more to take part in the City's
Wagon Plays. The dates will be 11th and 18th July 2010. Some financing
will be needed for costumes and the wagon.
The Annual General Meeting, April 2009
-
The 2009 budget and accounts for 2008 were approved.
We do not expect to meet our commitments for the coming year.
-
The Wardens elected are Bob Cummings and Karl Jarvis.
The Stewards elected are Bob Catley and Melanie Drewicz.
Grace Allen, Chris Sparks, Sue Whittaker, John Whittaker and Dorothy
Holden were all accepted onto the Church Council. Retiring Warden,
Harry Telfer, spoke of the condition of the building and was given
much appreciation.
-
Nancy and Rory spoke personally of the last year
which has had difficulties as well as a great sense of fulfilment.
They work well as a team.
-
A list of chuch activities over the last year was
compiled. It was very encouraging to see new ventures.
-
The future is uncertain for clergy staffing. It
is hoped that a new Anglican Chaplain will be appointed in the next
year, but while that person will have a base in Heslington Church
they will be free to attend other churches in York to which students
go. What happens when Nancy leaves has not yet been decided, but she
is not leaving for some time yet.
-
For the first year the numbers on our membership
list have grown. A display of our ecumenical make-up will be put on
the notice board.
March Church Council Meeting
-
The church financial situation is still giving
cause for concern. Financial advisers from Diocese, Deanery and Circuit
gave advice. The 2008 accounts were passed.
- The Council voted to begin exploration of transferring to York Deanery
from Derwent Deanery.
- There is to be a Summer Fete to raise funds. Date will probably 13th
June.
- Bob Catley and Harry Telfer were warmly thanked as Steward and Warden.
There will be elections of new Warden and Steward at the annual meeting
on 30th April.
|